Birds of Passage, Painting by Geoffrey Teale Chalmers, 2023
Idealization and devaluation are psychological processes that can strongly influence how individuals experience themselves and others in relationships. Idealization occurs when someone perceives another person as exceptionally good, admirable, nearly flawless, or perfect, usually overlooking their limitations or imperfections. Devaluation, in contrast, involves perceiving that same person as disappointing, inadequate, not good enough, or entirely negative. These shifts in perception can create emotional instability within relationships, especially when individuals struggle to reconcile both positive and negative qualities in themselves and others. From a psychodynamic perspective, idealization and devaluation are usually understood as unconscious defence mechanisms that protect individuals from difficult emotions, internal conflicts, traumas, and fears associated with intimacy and attachment.
The origins of idealization and devaluation can often be traced to early childhood experiences and relationships with primary caregivers. When emotional needs are inconsistently met, individuals may develop internal representations of others as either entirely nurturing or entirely rejecting. These early relational experiences can influence how people perceive and respond to significant relationships later in life. For example, someone who experienced unpredictable affection or criticism during childhood may idealize a romantic partner who initially provides reassurance and emotional security. However, when that partner inevitably disappoints them, feelings of rejection or abandonment may emerge, leading to a sudden shift towards devaluation. These reactions may show unresolved emotional experiences rather than the actual qualities or intentions of the other person.
A key concept in understanding idealization and devaluation is splitting, a defence mechanism where individuals struggle to integrate positive and negative aspects of themselves or others into an entire understanding. In this, individuals may alternate between viewing them as entirely good or entirely bad instead of recognizing that someone can be both caring and frustrating. This process can temporarily reduce anxiety by simplifying emotionally complex experiences, but it may also contribute to unstable relationships, interpersonal conflict, misunderstandings, and difficulties maintaining emotional closeness. Idealization can create unrealistic expectations of others, while devaluation may emerge when those expectations are not fulfilled. This pattern can reinforce feelings of disappointment, mistrust, hurt, and emotional insecurity over time.
Landscape with Ochre Lands, Painting by Philippe Janin, 2019
Idealization and devaluation may also act as important psychological functions related to self-esteem, vulnerability, self-concept, and the fear of abandonment. Idealizing another person can provide a sense of safety, belonging, warmth, or emotional completeness, particularly when individuals experience underlying feelings of inadequacy or uncertainty about their own worth. Oppositely, devaluation may protect against feelings of dependency, shame, helplessness, or anticipated rejection. Individuals may unconsciously attempt to regain a sense of control and distance themselves from the vulnerability associated with attachment by dismissing or criticizing someone who has become emotionally significant. Although these processes can occur in many relationships, they may become especially visible when emotional intimacy activates unresolved conflicts or painful relational experiences.
Psychodynamic psychotherapy provides an opportunity for patients to explore the unconscious patterns and emotional experiences underlying idealization and devaluation. Through the therapeutic relationship, patients may begin to recognize how earlier attachment experiences, internalized relationship patterns, and unconscious defence mechanisms influence their perceptions of themselves and others. At times, idealization or devaluation may also come up within the therapeutic relationship itself, which can offer opportunities to understand these dynamics as they come up. Psychodynamic psychotherapy seeks to understand their psychological meaning and protective functions instead of viewing these responses as intentional or inherently problematic. Over time, this process may help patients develop greater emotional awareness, tolerate disappointment and ambivalence, and establish more stable, realistic, and emotionally fulfilling relationships.

